Butterscotch Christmas Cookies

Welcome back to my Kitchen. The holiday season is a truly magical time of year, especially for us bakers. Christmas brings the joy of baking our favorite treats and sharing them with our loved ones.

Among the many recipes that capture the essence of this festive time, there’s one cookie that stands out. Yes, you guessed it right, Butterscotch Christmas Cookies!

This delightful treat isn’t your run-of-the-mill cookie. They’re like little pieces of holiday joy, each bite melting in your mouth, leaving behind a rich, indulgent taste that perfectly complements the holiday spirit.

The star ingredient, butterscotch chips, gives these cookies a unique and delightful twist that’s hard to resist. So, if you’re looking for a new Christmas cookie recipe to share with your family, or maybe even to leave out for Santa, you’re in the right place!

Why These Cookies Are Exceptional

We all have that one ingredient that, when added to any recipe, just takes the dish to another level. In our Christmas cookies, that superstar is the butterscotch chips.

These little nuggets of sweetness pack a whole lot of flavor, that makes these cookies exceptional and a beloved treat.

Butterscotch chips bring a rich, caramel-like flavor profile, giving a hint of toffee and a touch of saltiness, to balance the sweetness. When baked, they melt beautifully, creating pockets of delectable creaminess throughout the cookies.

This delightful contrast between the buttery cookie dough and the distinct butterscotch notes sets these cookies apart.

In addition, butterscotch chips offer a pleasing texture variation. As you bite into the cookie, you get the tender crumble of the cookie dough, complemented by the gooey richness of the melted butterscotch.

It’s a match made in heaven that adds an element of surprise to each bite.

Making Butterscotch Christmas Cookies

Baking cookies is an art, and like any art form, it requires precision and care, especially when you’re working with standout ingredients like butterscotch chips.

Here, we’re going to walk through the creation process, focusing on key steps that ensure your Butterscotch Christmas Cookies turn out beautifully every time.

Step One

Step one involves creaming together butter, powdered sugar, and vanilla until it’s fluffy and fully combined. This step is crucial as it ensures your cookies have a light, delicate texture. Remember, the lighter the butter-sugar mixture, the softer your cookies will be.

Step Two

Next, you’ll be mixing in flour and salt, gradually integrating it into your fluffy butter mixture. This step ensures all the ingredients are well distributed, making for a uniform, cohesive dough.

It’s important to add the flour gradually, allowing it to fully incorporate before adding more. This helps avoid over-mixing, which can make your cookies turn out tough.

Step Three

Finally, comes the most exciting part! Adding the butterscotch chips! Mixing them in with your hands allows you to feel the distribution of chips throughout the dough, ensuring every cookie will have its fair share of butterscotch goodness.

Once your dough is ready, you’ll shape and arrange them on a cookie sheet. These little mounds of dough will then transform into beautifully baked cookies in the oven.

It’s key to keep an eye on them as they bake, waiting for the moment when their bottoms turn a lovely golden brown.

Step Four

After they’ve cooled a bit, each cookie gets a gentle covering in powdered sugar. This not only adds an extra touch of sweetness, but also gives them a festive, snow-dusted appearance.

Making Butterscotch Christmas cookies

Alternatives for Butterscotch Chips

We understand that sometimes, despite your best intentions, you might find your pantry lacking that one crucial ingredient you need. In the case of our Christmas cookies, it might be the butterscotch chips.

But fret not, there are alternatives that you can use without compromising too much on the taste and texture of your cookies.

One such alternative is caramel chips. They also offer a sweet, slightly salty flavor profile similar to butterscotch, and when baked, they melt into pockets of gooey goodness that add a delightful texture to your cookies.

Another option is white chocolate chips. While they lack the distinct toffee-like flavor of butterscotch, they bring a creamy sweetness that pairs well with the buttery cookie dough.

If you’re feeling adventurous, you could even try peanut butter chips. These offer a unique twist, providing a nutty, slightly salty contrast that complements the sweetness of the cookie dough nicely.

While these alternatives may not perfectly replicate the taste of butterscotch chips, they each bring their own unique charm to the recipe. And who knows, you might even stumble upon a new flavor combination that you love!

Spicing it Up: Mix-in Options for Your Cookies

While the butterscotch chips are indeed the highlight of this recipe, there’s always room for a little creativity in the kitchen.

Adding a mix-in or two to your cookie dough can introduce new flavor profiles and textures, making each batch of cookies uniquely your own. Here are some ideas to consider:

  1. Nuts: A handful of chopped pecans, walnuts, or almonds can add a wonderful crunch that contrasts beautifully with the softness of the cookie and the texture of the melted butterscotch. Plus, the earthy flavors of the nuts pair well with the sweetness of the butterscotch.
  2. Chocolate Chips: Adding a few chocolate chips can turn these cookies into a decadent treat. The rich, dark flavors of the chocolate work surprisingly well with the sweet, creamy notes of the butterscotch.
  3. Dried Fruit: For a festive twist, try adding some finely chopped dried cranberries or cherries to the dough. The tartness of the fruit provides a wonderful counterbalance to the sweetness of the cookies, and they add beautiful specks of color as well.

Remember, these are just suggestions. Feel free to let your creativity guide you. The joy of baking is in experimenting and finding what you love.

Just make sure to maintain a balance so that the additional mix-ins enhance the butterscotch flavor rather than overpowering it.

Butterscotch Christmas cookies with sugar

Preserving Your Cookie Dough

With the hustle and bustle of the holiday season, it’s always a good idea to have a plan for making things a little easier. One such strategy with these Butterscotch Christmas Cookies is to prepare the dough ahead of time and freeze it for later use.

So yes, you certainly can freeze your cookie dough. Here’s how to do it properly:

Flash Freeze

Start by shaping your cookie dough into balls as you would before baking. Arrange these dough balls on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.

Place the entire tray in the freezer for about an hour, or until the dough balls are firm. This process, known as flash freezing, ensures that your cookies won’t stick together when you store them.

Bag Them

Once the dough balls are frozen, transfer them into airtight containers or freezer bags. You can store them in your freezer for up to three months! It’s a good idea to label the container or bag with the date, so you’ll know how long they’ve been stored.

When you’re ready to bake, just take out the number of cookies you want and let them sit at room temperature for a few minutes. Then bake them as per the recipe, adding a couple of extra minutes to the baking time.

How to Store Your Butterscotch Christmas Cookies

Congratulations! You’ve crafted a batch of delicious Butterscotch Christmas Cookies. Now, let’s talk about how to store your baked goodies, just so they stay fresh and flavorful for as long as possible.

After you’ve allowed your cookies to cool completely on the baking rack, it’s time to think about storage. Storing your cookies properly is just as crucial as each step of the baking process in ensuring your treats stay at their best.

For short-term storage, a good old-fashioned cookie jar does the trick. Make sure it’s airtight to keep the cookies from drying out. Lining the bottom of the jar with a piece of parchment or wax paper can also help absorb any excess moisture, keeping your cookies crisp.

If you’re looking to store your cookies for a week or more, consider using airtight containers or zip-lock bags. Again, make sure the cookies have cooled completely before storing them to avoid condensation build-up, which could make them soggy.

Why Your Butterscotch Cookies Will Be a Hit

Christmas is a time for joy, togetherness, and of course, delightful treats. This Butterscotch Christmas Cookie recipe hits all the right notes and is bound to be a standout hit in your holiday spread. Here’s why these cookies are sure to impress:

The Flavor

First and foremost, the flavor profile is exquisite. The rich, creamy butterscotch chips in a delicate, buttery cookie dough make for an indulgent treat that’s not overly sweet.

They’re comforting, yet they offer a unique twist on the traditional Christmas cookie, setting them apart from the usual holiday desserts.

The Texture

They have an amazing texture. From the soft, melt-in-your-mouth cookie dough to the gooey butterscotch chips, each bite is a delightful experience.

Plus, the dusting of powdered sugar not only gives the cookies a festive look but adds a slight crunch to the outside.

The Versatility

These cookies offer versatility! Whether you’re serving them as a dessert after your Christmas dinner, packing them as a sweet treat in your children’s lunchboxes, or even leaving a plate out for Santa, they fit perfectly into every holiday scenario.

Butterscotch Christmas cookies with sugar

Butterscotch Christmas Cookies

Gwen Xavier
This twist on the classic cookies will surprise you with a pop of flavor in each bite. The recipe also includes simple swaps to try to create other varieties of Cookies, including the classic instructions.
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Rest Time 5 minutes
Total Time 25 minutes
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Servings 24 Cookies
Calories 210 kcal


  • 1 Cup Butterscotch chips
  • 1 Cup Powdered sugar
  • 1 Cup Softened Butter
  • 1 Tsp Vanilla
  • 2 1/4 Cups All-purpose Flour
  • 1/2 Tsp Salt


  • Preheat oven to 375 degrees
  • In a large mixing bowl, add butter, 1/2 cup powdered sugar, and vanilla. Beat with an electric mixer until fluffy and completely combined. 
  • Add salt to the flour and stir together. Slowly add flour to the butter-sugar mixture using the electric mixture until the dough comes together. 
  • Using your hands, mix in the butterscotch chips so that it is scattered through-out the dough. 
  • Roll the dough into 1 inch balls, press them slightly with a fork, and place on cookie sheets. 
  • Bake for 9–14 minutes until they are slightly brown. Remove from oven and cool for a few minutes, until you are able to touch them. 
  • Sprinkle powdered sugar on the top until you are satisfied. Set on a rack to cool. Repeat with the remaining cookies. 
Keyword Butterscotch, christmas, cookies

More Cookie Recipes

Looking for more tasty cookies? I have just what you need:

Photo of author

Gwen Xavier

Gwen Xavier, the culinary genius behind Finding Sanity In Our Crazy Life, initially crafted her food-focused website out of a necessity to find joy in cooking. Over the years, her relationship with the kitchen transformed from a mere duty to a fervent passion. Today, Gwen shares a variety of recipes on a daily basis, curating meals that cater to diverse tastes and family preferences, proving that cooking can indeed become a love affair!

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating