10 Best Pizza Spots In Gatlinburg

Welcome to Gatlinburg, a charming mountain resort city found in the heart of Tennessee, known for its vibrant local cuisine. A gourmet journey through this city is nothing short of magical, filled with mouth-watering delicacies that reflect its rich heritage.

Yet, among the soulful southern barbecue spots and gourmet fine dining, there’s a food scene that’s often overlooked, but equally impressive, Pizza!

Gatlinburg’s pizza landscape is a tapestry of flavors, a delightful mix of traditional and contemporary, local and global. All baked to perfection and presented with a flair that is distinctly Gatlinburg.

So, whether you’re a lover of thin-crust Neapolitan, a hearty deep-dish, or a gourmet fusion style, there’s a slice of heaven waiting for you in this scenic city.

Join me, as I embark on a flavor-packed tour to explore and unveil Gatlinburg’s Top 10 Pizza Spots! Each pizzeria a testament to the city’s culinary diversity and creativity.

1. Ski Mountain Pizza

Ski Mountain Pizza

Imagine biting into a pizza slice, the thin yet firm crust crackling delicately, the rich flavors of the sauce blending beautifully with the freshness of the toppings.

Now imagine this experience at a cozy, family-owned spot, where the love for pizza is as tangible as the mesmerizing view of the mountains outside.

Welcome to Ski Mountain Pizza, a relatively new addition to the Gatlinburg pizza scene, already making waves with their delicious pies.

The brainchild of local culinary enthusiasts, Ski Mountain Pizza prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Their dough is made in-house daily, promising a light, flavorful crust that’s the perfect foundation for their exquisite pizza creations.

The main attraction of their menu is the classic Margherita. It’s a wonderful balance of ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, and creamy mozzarella. But don’t stop there!

Their extensive menu also features more adventurous options, like the “Ski Slope Supreme,” loaded with a variety of veggies and meats to keep your taste buds intrigued.

One visit to Ski Mountain Pizza, and you’ll understand why it’s quickly becoming a must-visit for pizza lovers in Gatlinburg. Don’t forget to check out their website to browse their full menu and plan your visit.

2. Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria

Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria

For those who cherish the traditional taste of an authentic Italian pizza, your destination in Gatlinburg should unquestionably be the Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria.

This family-owned establishment has been delighting pizza enthusiasts for decades with their classic recipes passed down through generations.

The moment you walk in, the warm, inviting atmosphere makes you feel like you’ve been transported straight to a charming café in Italy.

The aroma of simmering marinara sauce, freshly baked dough, and sizzling toppings create an irresistible sensory allure that’s only matched by the taste of their pizzas.

Every pizza at Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria is a testament to their dedication to authenticity and quality. Their standout pizza is the classic Pepperoni, a simple yet flavorful feast that highlights the quality of their ingredients.

For a change, the Alfredo Pizza provides a creamy, indulgent twist that’s hard to resist.

A visit to Gatlinburg would be incomplete without a meal at Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria. Experience the best of Italian pizzas right here in the Smoky Mountains. For more details, check out their website and plan your visit.

3. Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg

Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg

Get ready for a kaleidoscope of flavors and a psychedelic atmosphere at Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg. As the name suggests, this pizzeria is all about having a mellow time, enjoying out-of-this-world pizza, and diving into a unique dining experience.

One step into Mellow Mushroom, and you’ll find yourself embraced by its groovy, colorful ambiance, a playful tribute to the free-spirited culture of the ’70s.

But the true hero here, of course, is their handcrafted pizza. Prepared with fresh dough and an array of gourmet toppings, each pizza is a delight for the senses.

Their Magic Mushroom Soup Pizza, with its blend of shiitake, button, and Portobello mushrooms, caramelized onions, and MontAmoré cheese, is a crowd-pleaser.

However, their adventurous spirit shines in unique offerings like the Thai Dye Pizza, with curried chicken, fresh cucumbers, and a sweet swirl of Thai chili sauce.

If you’re looking for a pizza experience that’s as exciting for your taste buds as it is visually, Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg should be on your list. For a sneak peek at their other wondrous creations, visit their website.

4. New York Pizza & Pasta

New York Pizza & Pasta

It’s time to take a culinary detour from the Smoky Mountains to the bustling streets of New York without leaving Gatlinburg! Welcome to New York Pizza & Pasta! A hub that brings the iconic flavors of New York-style pizza right to your plate.

The New York-style pizza is renowned for its thin, crisp, and foldable crust, slightly sweet sauce, and a generous layer of cheese, and this place has perfected it.

You can almost hear the city’s hustle and bustle with each bite, the explosion of flavors resonating with the vibrant spirit of the Big Apple.

The pizzeria’s Classic New York Cheese Pizza is a homage to simplicity, letting the fundamental elements of the pie shine.

For a meatier delight, their Meat Lovers Pizza piles on the pepperoni, ham, beef, and sausage, ensuring a satisfying bite each time.

Whether you’re a homesick New Yorker or a pizza lover seeking a classic experience! New York Pizza & Pasta provides a perfect slice of the city’s beloved pie. To make a reservation, give them a call at (865) 436-9300.

5. Luigi’s Pizzeria

Luigi’s Pizzeria

Prepare to be whisked away to the Italian countryside with a visit to LUIGI’S PIZZERIA. This local favorite, nestled in the heart of Gatlinburg, is known for its friendly service, charming ambiance, and, most importantly, its irresistible pizzas.

LUIGI’S PIZZERIA has been serving its customers a piece of Italy with their traditional techniques, high-quality ingredients, and an unwavering passion for pizza-making.

Their delicious pizza pies are a testament to their commitment to preserving authentic Italian flavors while still adding a touch of Gatlinburg charm.

LUIGI’S Pizzeria puts out a namesake Special Pizza that’s a taste bud’s rollercoaster.

A medley of toppings, fresh mushrooms, crisp onions, green peppers, tantalizing black olives, zesty pepperoni, robust beef, and hearty sausage. They all come together in a delectable harmony.

For those who prefer their pizza with a green thumb, fear not. LUIGI’S has got you covered with a veggie-packed delight.

Their Vegetarian Pizza is a testament to the fact that taste doesn’t have to be sacrificed for the sake of veggies. Its colorful array of fresh ingredients sings a beautiful, flavor-filled aria that dances on your tongue.

In essence, LUIGI’S Pizzeria serves up pizzas that are a true salute to Italian culinary artistry. It’s more than a meal. It’s an invitation to savor freshness and flavor in every bite.

So, if you’re craving a pizza that’s fresh, flavorful, and true to its Italian roots, LUIGI’S PIZZERIA is the place to be. Be sure to check out their website for more information on their offerings.

6. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria

Big Daddy's Pizzeria

If pizza that packs a punch is your thing, then get ready to play in the flavor arena that is Big Daddy’s Pizzeria.

This pizza place isn’t just known, it’s celebrated for bold flavors that take your taste buds on a thrilling ride. It’s a spot of joy and warmth, where families gather and the commitment to freshness doesn’t just show, it shines in every single bite.

The pizza-making journey at Big Daddy’s Pizzeria? Think of it as an elaborate ballet. The magic begins with the dough. Crafted from scratch daily, it’s left to rise at a leisurely pace, all in the name of flavor.

Next up, the toppings, handpicked, meticulously placed. Cheese sprinkled with a free hand, in an almost lavish manner. And then, the crowning glory, the pizza is lovingly introduced to a wood-burning oven. The result? A finish that’s as crisp as a fall morning.

A menu that’s a festival of pizza goodness awaits you, but for the meat-lovers out there, it’s the Big Daddy Meat Pizza that’s the real star of the show. A savory combination of hickory-smoked beef, Italian sausage, and pepperoni, it’s a joyride for the senses.

For a lighter yet equally delicious option, the Vegetarian Pie offers a fresh and flavorful feast.

Make no mistake! A visit to Big Daddy’s Pizzeria is more than just a meal. It’s a grand celebration of pizza in all its glorious, cheesy, saucy, crispy goodness. You can check out their website for a preview of what awaits you.

7. Taste of Italy

Brimming with the heartwarming flavors of Italian home-cooking, Taste of Italy offers a truly unique pizza experience. This pizzeria, tucked away in Gatlinburg, celebrates Italian cuisine in all its glory, with pizza taking center stage.

Taste of Italy is the place where old-world culinary traditions meet modern expectations.

It’s where dough is still hand-kneaded with love, the tomato sauce simmers until it reaches perfection, and the toppings are fresh and locally sourced! Delivering the true taste of Italy in every slice.

The Taste of Italy Special Pizza, a combination of Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, and peppers, is a must-try.

Another standout is their Margherita Pizza, a classic done right! With a perfect balance of ripe tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fresh basil.

So, if you’re seeking an authentic Italian experience with your pizza, look no further. Taste of Italy promises a pizza journey that’s as delicious as it is unforgettable. To plan your visit, check out their website.

8. Slice Pizza Bakery

Slice Pizza Bakery

In the heart of Gatlinburg, Slice Pizza Bakery has been serving people with their beautifully crafted, artisanal pies.

This eatery is a creative blend of traditional pizza making with innovative culinary techniques! Resulting in some of the most distinct pizzas in town.

Slice Pizza Bakery believes in quality over everything else. That’s why their pizzas begin with a freshly rolled dough, topped with hand-crushed San Marzano tomatoes for the sauce, and a blend of the best cheeses.

From there, it’s all about the toppings, which range from classic favorites to inventive combinations.

Their BBQ Chicken Pizza, with its tangy sauce, grilled chicken, red onions, and cilantro, is a fan favorite.

But for the truly adventurous, the Shrimp Scampi Pizza, loaded with garlic-marinated shrimp, fresh tomatoes, and basil, offers an unexpected delight.

If you’re looking to step off the beaten pizza path and try something truly unique, a visit to Slice Pizza Bakery is a must. Find out more about their exciting pizza options on their website.

9. Stanga’s Big Slice

Stanga’s Big Slice isn’t just another pizza place. It’s a local legend! This charming pizzeria, born and raised in Gatlinburg, has been serving pizza that’s as big in size as it is in flavor.

With each slice, you taste a bit of Gatlinburg’s spirit, the community’s love for good food, and the unmistakable hint of genuine hospitality.

At Stanga’s Big Slice, the pizzas are handcrafted with care. From the dough that’s kneaded fresh every day, to the vibrant sauce made from ripe tomatoes, to the generous layer of melted cheese. And finally, the wide variety of quality toppings.

Their signature Stanga’s Big Slice Special is an absolute must-try. This hefty slice comes loaded with all your favorite toppings, guaranteeing a flavor-packed experience with every bite.

For vegetarians, the Veggie Slice is a rainbow of fresh, crisp veggies on a wonderfully cheesy backdrop.

Stanga’s Big Slice is more than a pizza place, it’s a piece of Gatlinburg’s culinary heart. Give them a call at (865) 548-5959 to plan your visit.

10. Smoky Mountain Brewery

Smoky Mountain Brewery

Ending our pizza journey on a high note, we land at Smoky Mountain Brewery. Yes, you read that right, a brewery. But don’t let the name trick you!

Well-loved for its broad array of artisanal beers, this haunt is also home to some of the city’s most craved-for pizzas. Quite the surprising pair, isn’t it?

In a unique fusion, Smoky Mountain Brewery marries the art of brewing with pizza mastery. Their stone-fired pizzas are a feast for the senses, the crust offering a balance between crunch and fluffiness that’s beloved by regulars and wanderers alike.

The star of the show? The Ale Steak & Cheese Pizza. A tantalizing medley of lean steak slivers, vibrant peppers, onions, and mushrooms, it’s a hit with the crowds.

Those who favor a fiery kick, take note of the Cajun Chicken Pizza. Garnished with smoky chicken, fresh bell peppers, and onions, it promises to thrill your tastebuds.

In pursuit of a pizza escapade that strays from the ordinary yet leaves a lasting impression? Your quest ends at Smoky Mountain Brewery.

Pair a delicious pizza with one of their house-brewed beers for a meal to remember. Visit their website to explore their menu and brewing selection.

Photo of author

Gwen Xavier

Gwen Xavier, the culinary genius behind Finding Sanity In Our Crazy Life, initially crafted her food-focused website out of a necessity to find joy in cooking. Over the years, her relationship with the kitchen transformed from a mere duty to a fervent passion. Today, Gwen shares a variety of recipes on a daily basis, curating meals that cater to diverse tastes and family preferences, proving that cooking can indeed become a love affair!

Leave a Comment